When upgrading a home in Metro Detroit, homeowners want a system that handles heavy snow and ice dams effectively. However, the durability of your investment depends entirely on the installation quality. To ensure your project lasts, you need to understand standing seam metal roofs common mistakes to avoid. Cutting corners during a roof replacement or repair often leads to expensive leaks and structural issues down the road.
At Best Choice Roofing, we service Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties. We see the aftermath of poor installations regularly. Below is a breakdown of the specific errors that occur with standing seam metal roofs and how to ensure your contractor avoids them.
Michigan’s temperature swings are brutal. In Metro Detroit, we see summer days hit 90 degrees and winter nights drop below zero. Metal expands and contracts significantly with these temperature changes.
The Mistake: Installers fasten the metal panels too tightly to the roof deck or use the wrong type of clip. If the panel is pinned down rigidly, it cannot move. This causes the metal to buckle, warp, or create "oil canning" (visual waviness in the metal). In extreme cases, the fasteners can shear off, or the seams can pop open, allowing water infiltration.
The Fix: Reputable roofing crews use floating clips or sliding attachments that secure the roof against wind uplift while allowing the metal to expand and contract along its length. When reviewing standing seam metal roofs, ask specifically about the clip system being used.
Many homeowners believe that because metal is waterproof, the underlayment underneath is secondary. This is a dangerous assumption, especially in Michigan.
The Mistake: Using standard asphalt felt paper (tar paper) instead of a synthetic high-temperature underlayment. Felt paper can absorb moisture if water gets behind the metal due to capillary action or wind-driven rain. Furthermore, metal roofs can get very hot in the summer sun, which can degrade low-quality underlayments, causing them to stick to the metal or disintegrate.
The Fix: We recommend a high-quality, synthetic underlayment that is slip-resistant and designed to handle high temperatures. This creates a critical secondary water barrier. If ice dams form or wind drives rain under the ridge cap, this layer protects your home’s structure.
The leaks we fix on standing seam metal roofs are rarely in the field of the panels. They almost always occur at the penetrations—chimneys, skylights, vents, and dormers.
The Mistake: Using a generic flashing or attempting to seal transitions with only caulk or tar. Caulk degrades under UV exposure and thermal movement. Another common error is using "counter-flashing" that is not properly tucked into the masonry or routed behind the siding.
The Fix: Flashing must be detailed specifically for the roof plane it intersects. For masonry chimneys, we cut a reglet into the brick and tuck the metal flashing in, sealing it with high-grade masonry sealant. For walls, step flashing must be woven into the shingles or siding courses. This ensures water is directed over the top of the roofing materials rather than running behind them.
Not all metal is created equal. Big box stores often sell roofing materials that look adequate but lack the longevity required for a Michigan climate.
The Mistake: Opting for a thinner gauge (29-gauge) to save money, or choosing a paint system (like polyester) that chalks and fades quickly. Thinner metal is more susceptible to oil canning and damage from hail. In Metro Detroit, hail storms are frequent, and denting is a major concern.
The Fix: For residential standing seam metal roofs, we typically recommend 24-gauge or 26-gauge steel with a Kynar or Hylar coating (PVDF). These coatings resist fading and chalking, maintaining the warranty and the appearance of the home for decades.
Vent pipes, exhaust fans, and plumbing stacks require boots that move with the roof.
The Mistake: Installing standard rubber pipe boots meant for asphalt shingles on a metal roof. The metal movement will eventually tear the rubber boot apart. Additionally, if the boot is not flattened correctly or if the seam is not sealed at the collar, it becomes a prime entry point for water.
The Fix: Use specifically designed metal roof pipe boots that have a flexible rubber base and a metal collar that matches the roof color. These are designed to accommodate the movement of standing seam metal roofs without failing.
While metal roofs can shed water effectively, they still have minimum pitch requirements.
The Mistake: Installing a standing seam roof on a roof pitch that is too low for the specific panel profile chosen. Without sufficient slope, water can pool or "wash back" under the seams during heavy wind-driven rain—a common occurrence during severe storms in Macomb and Oakland counties.
The Fix: A licensed inspector will verify the pitch. For low-slope applications (between 2:12 and 3:12), mechanical seaming or specific panels with wider pans and taller ribs are required to prevent capillary action where water wicks up the seam.
If you already have a metal roof or are considering one, a professional set of eyes is invaluable. At Best Choice Roofing, we provide free inspections and estimates. We look for the stress points mentioned above: loose clips, failing sealant, and damaged flashing.
We are a licensed, insured Metro Detroit roofing crew. We understand local building codes and the specific weather challenges of Southeast Michigan. Whether you need roof leak repair, storm and hail damage assessment, or a full roof replacement, we provide upfront pricing.
We never quote a firm price online because every roof is unique. The roofer confirms exact pricing after a free, thorough inspection of your property.
Storm damage in Michigan is often deceptive. Hail hits on metal can bruise the coating or dent the ribs without puncturing the surface immediately, compromising the roof's lifespan over time. If you suspect storm damage, navigating the insurance claim process can be difficult.
We offer full insurance-claim help. We document the damage thoroughly, meet with adjusters, and ensure the scope of work covers the necessary repairs to restore your roof to its pre-storm condition. We offer same-day response on active leaks to minimize interior damage to your home.
Standing seam metal roofs are a premium investment that offers superior longevity when installed correctly. However, the margin for error is small. Avoiding these common mistakes requires hiring a contractor who understands the mechanics of the roofing materials, not just someone who knows how to nail down shingles.
If you are in Wayne, Oakland, or Macomb County and want to ensure your metal roof is installed or repaired to the highest standards, contact Best Choice Roofing. We handle everything from flashing and vents to gutters and full roof replacements.
Get a Free Inspection
Don't wait for a small mistake to become a major leak. Call us today at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.