In Metro Detroit, our freeze-thaw cycles are brutal on residential roofing. When snow sits on your roof, it melts, runs down to the cold eaves, and refreezes. This creates ice dams that force water back up under your shingles. The only thing standing between that water and your interior sheathing is a rubberized membrane known as ice & water shield.
However, simply buying the product isn't enough. To ensure your home stays dry, you need to understand the ice & water shield common mistakes to avoid during installation or replacement. We see these errors daily during storm damage inspections across Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. Fixing them after the shingles are on is expensive and labor-intensive.
For a deeper dive into the technical specifications and benefits of this material, check out our comprehensive guide on ice & water shield.
The most common mistake is under-application. Building codes typically require ice & water shield to extend from the eave edge up the roof at least two feet past the exterior wall line. In Michigan, that is often the absolute minimum—not the best practice.
Many homeowners or budget contractors will only run a single 3-foot roll from the edge. If your roof overhang is two feet, you only have one foot of protection past the warm wall. During a heavy winter, ice dams can grow several feet up the roof. If the dam breaches past that 3-foot mark, water hits the bare felt paper or roof deck.
The Fix: We recommend installing a minimum of 6 feet of ice & water shield at the eaves. In areas with severe ice damming history, covering the entire lower roof section (up to 10 feet) provides the necessary buffer against deep freeze events.
Eaves are the primary concern, but they aren't the only danger zone. Valleys—the internal angles where two roof slopes meet—carry a massive volume of water. If your roofer only applies standard felt or synthetic underlayment in the valleys, you are risking a leak.
One nail hole in the wrong place in a valley can channel water directly into your living room.
The Fix: Valleys should always be lined with a heavy-duty layer of ice & water shield. Furthermore, this material must be installed around all penetrations—chimneys, skylights, and plumbing vents. These areas are where wind-driven rain exploits small gaps. The membrane seals around the nails used to secure the flashing, creating a watertight gasket that standard underlayment cannot provide.
Ice & water shield is sticky. It adheres to the wood deck and to itself. However, it must be installed in a "shingle fashion." This means the upper course must overlap the lower course. Water flows downhill; if you install the upper piece under the lower piece, water will run right between the seams and into the house.
We also see what contractors call "bird-bathing"—where the material is laid loosely without pressing it firmly into the deck. If there are wrinkles or air pockets, water can pool there or migrate laterally.
The Fix: Ensure the crew overlaps the rows by at least 3 to 6 inches (horizontally) and follows the overlap pattern vertically. The material must be rolled tight to eliminate trapped air, ensuring the adhesive seal activates completely.
Ice & water shield creates a seal that is almost impossible to remove without tearing it apart. While this is great for waterproofing, it is disastrous if the roof deck underneath isn't sound.
If a contractor installs this membrane over damp, snowy, or rotted sheathing, they are trapping moisture against the wood. Over time, this accelerates rot. Eventually, the deck softens, and your foot might go right through the roof during the next inspection. The integrity of the roofing materials relies entirely on the substrate they are attached to.
The Fix: Inspect the deck before covering it. If there are soft spots, they must be replaced. If the wood is wet from rain the day before, it needs to dry out. At Best Choice Roofing, we won't cover a deck we wouldn't walk on ourselves.
Not all ice & water shield is the same. Most standard versions are asphalt-modified with a polyethylene surface. They are designed for cold weather and watertightness. However, in high-heat environments—specifically under metal roofing or in areas with extreme sun exposure like the south-facing slopes of a Detroit home—standard granular or smooth surface shields can slide or melt.
If you are installing a metal roof, you generally need a high-temperature, heat-resistant membrane specifically designed to withstand the thermal transfer of metal.
The Fix: Discuss the roof type with your contractor. If you have a metal roof or extreme sun exposure, verify that the membrane is rated for high-temperature applications to prevent slumping or adhesion failure.
The drip edge is the metal flashing installed at the eave and rakes to direct water away from the fascia and into the gutter. A frequent failure point is the relationship between the drip edge and the ice & water shield.
The best practice (and code in many jurisdictions) is to install the ice & water shield first at the eave, extending over the fascia, and then install the drip edge metal over the membrane. Alternatively, some methods call for the drip edge first, then the membrane installed over the metal flange. The mistake is leaving a gap between the metal and the membrane, or having the membrane terminate short of the drip edge.
If water gets behind the drip edge because the membrane wasn't lapped correctly, it rots the fascia board.
The Fix: Ensure a continuous seal. Whether the metal goes over or under the membrane depends on the specific product specs and local code preference, but there must be no gap where water can migrate behind the flashing.
You can buy the best roofing materials on the market, but they will fail if the installation crew rushes. In the Metro Detroit area, we see storm chasers and less experienced crews who treat underlayment as an afterthought. They throw it down fast to get to the shingles.
At Best Choice Roofing, we treat the underlayment system as the most critical part of the roof. If the barrier fails, the shingles are just decoration. We are a licensed, insured crew serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties. We know how Michigan winters attack roof structures, and we install accordingly.
If you have storm damage or hail damage, your insurance claim should cover the removal of the old roof down to the deck and the installation of a proper waterproofing system. However, insurance adjusters don't always specify the exact quality of installation—that’s up to the roofer.
We offer full insurance-claim help. We work directly with your adjuster to ensure the scope of work includes proper protection against ice dams. We provide same-day response on active leaks to mitigate damage while you navigate the claims process.
It is difficult to inspect ice & water shield once the shingles are installed. The only time to verify it is done right is during the installation or if you are dealing with a reroof where the old materials are torn off.
If you are unsure about the integrity of your roof’s underlayment, or if you are seeing signs of ice dam damage (water stains on ceilings, damp insulation), don't wait for the next thaw.
We provide free inspections and estimates. We will climb up, assess the situation, and give you upfront pricing. We never quote a firm price online because every roof deck and every situation is unique; the roofer confirms exact pricing after a thorough, free inspection.
Call Best Choice Roofing at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com. We handle roof leak repair, storm and hail damage, shingle repair, full roof replacement, flashing, vents, and gutters.