Installing a new roof is a significant investment for Metro Detroit homeowners. When you choose high-quality architectural (dimensional) shingles, you expect durability and curb appeal. However, even the best roofing materials can fail if they aren't installed or maintained correctly. Knowing the architectural (dimensional) shingles common mistakes to avoid will save you money, time, and headaches down the road.
In Michigan, where we face freeze-thaw cycles, heavy snow, and strong winds, cutting corners is not an option. At Best Choice Roofing, we see the repercussions of poor installations daily. Below is a breakdown of the specific errors you need to watch out for to ensure your roof lasts its full lifespan.
One of the most overlooked aspects of a roofing project is airflow. Many homeowners focus solely on the shingles and ignore what is happening underneath. If your attic cannot breathe, the trapped heat and moisture will destroy your roof from the inside out.
In the summer, a poorly ventilated attic can reach temperatures exceeding 150°F. This excessive heat bakes the underside of the architectural (dimensional) shingles, causing them to age prematurely and lose their protective granules. In the winter, warm air from the living space rises into the attic. Without proper exhaust, this heat melts the snow on the roof deck. When that water hits the cold eaves, it refreezes, creating ice dams. These ice dams push water under the shingles and into your home.
A proper system requires intake vents (soffits) and exhaust vents (ridge vents or box vents). If a contractor suggests covering up your vents or adding fewer vents than necessary to save money, that is a red flag.
It seems simple—nail the shingle to the roof. However, the physics of a roof system rely heavily on the nail placement. We frequently see repairs where nails were driven too high, too low, or at the wrong angle.
Most shingle manufacturers specify a "nail zone," usually about 1 to 2 inches above the cutouts (tabs). If nails are placed too high, the shingle is not secured to the deck and can be blown off by a strong Michigan storm. If nails are placed too low, they are visible and eventually puncture through the overlaying shingle, creating leak points.
Furthermore, using the wrong nail length is a critical error. Nails must penetrate the roof deck by at least ¾ of an inch. If the crew uses nails that are too short—often to prevent them from poking through the interior ceiling—the shingles will not hold. Conversely, over-driving nails with pneumatic guns can crush the matting of the shingle, creating a dimple that allows water to seep in.
In Metro Detroit, skipping ice and water protection is a recipe for disaster. Building codes generally require ice and water shield in the "valleys" of the roof and along the eaves (the first 2 to 3 feet up from the gutter).
This self-adhering membrane creates a waterproof barrier that seals around the nails. If a roofer installs standard felt paper (tar paper) in these vulnerable areas instead of ice and water shield, you are at high risk for leaks during ice dam season. We see this often during our free inspections; homeowners assume they have protection because they have a "new roof," only to find the cheapest underlayment was used.
Flashing is the metal material used to seal the joints where the roof meets a vertical surface, such as a chimney, dormer, or skylight. Leaks rarely happen in the middle of a shingle field; they almost always occur around flashing.
A common mistake is relying heavily on caulk or roof tar to seal these areas instead of using metal flashing. Tar dries out and cracks within a few years due to UV exposure. Step flashing must be woven into the shingles correctly. If a contractor simply slides a piece of metal under the shingles and slaps some caulk on it, it will fail.
Additionally, "re-flashing" often involves nailing new metal over old, rusted flashing. This covers the problem temporarily but does not fix the underlying corrosion. The correct method is to remove the old flashing, inspect the substrate, and install new, corrosion-resistant metal.
Michigan building code generally allows for two layers of shingles on a roof. However, just because you can do it doesn't mean you should. Installing a second layer of architectural (dimensional) shingles over an old layer is a major mistake.
The extra weight puts significant stress on your home’s rafters and truss system. More importantly, you cannot inspect the roof deck for rot or water damage if you don't tear off the old roof. New shingles require a flat, smooth surface to adhere and seal properly. Old shingles are often cupped, curled, or uneven. When you nail new shingles to an uneven surface, they do not lay flat, which compromises their wind resistance and aesthetic appearance. A complete tear-off is the only way to ensure the integrity of the roof deck.
The drip edge is the metal flashing installed at the eaves and rakes (edges) of the roof. Its job is to direct water away from the fascia and into the gutters.
A common error is installing the underlayment over the drip edge at the eaves (instead of under it) or failing to install it at the rakes entirely. If water runs down the roof and gets behind the gutter or fascia due to missing drip edge, it will eventually rot the wood framing. This is a detail that separates a professional job from a patch job. It costs very little in materials but prevents thousands of dollars in fascia and soffit repairs later.
Spotting these mistakes from the ground is nearly impossible for the average homeowner. A roof might look shiny and new from the street, but if the nail patterns are off or the flashing is sealed with tar, it is a ticking time bomb.
At Best Choice Roofing, we provide free inspections and upfront pricing. When we assess a roof, we look at these specific failure points. If you have storm damage or hail damage, navigating the insurance claim process can be just as complex as the installation itself. We offer full insurance-claim help to ensure you are covered for the repairs you actually need, not just a quick patch.
Most major shingle manufacturers offer limited lifetime warranties, but those warranties are often voided if the installation does not strictly follow their guidelines. If a contractor uses the wrong nails or fails to ventilate the attic properly, the manufacturer will not honor the claim when the shingles fail.
We serve Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and the surrounding Michigan counties. Our crew is licensed and insured, and we never quote a firm price online until we have physically inspected the roof. Every home is different, and an accurate diagnosis is required to give you a fair price.
If you suspect your roof has some of these installation errors, or if you just want a professional opinion before the next Michigan winter, give us a call.
Get a Professional Roof Inspection in Metro Detroit
Don't wait for a leak to appear in your living room. Best Choice Roofing offers same-day response on active leaks and storm damage. We provide free inspections, transparent estimates, and expert guidance on your roofing materials.
Call us today at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.