In Metro Detroit, roof valleys take a beating. Heavy snow loads in winter and driving rains in spring mean these critical intersection points channel thousands of gallons of water annually. When the system fails, it doesn't just drip; it pours into your attic and walls. If you are a homeowner facing leaks or visible wear, understanding roof valley repair common mistakes to avoid can save you thousands in remediation costs. Proper roof valley repair requires specific techniques suited for Michigan’s freeze-thaw cycles, yet many contractors and homeowners cut corners.
Below are the specific errors we see in Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties, and how to ensure your roof repair is done right the first time.
One of the most prevalent issues we encounter during inspections is the "bucket of tar" solution. A homeowner or a less experienced roofer sees a crack or a gap and slathers asphalt cement over it. While this might stop the leak for a few weeks, it is a temporary bandage, not a repair.
Tar dries out, cracks, and shrinks over time, especially under the intense UV exposure of a Michigan summer. Furthermore, applying tar over wet surfaces or debris traps moisture against the shingles and underlayment. This accelerates wood rot and deck deterioration. If you see a glob of black tar in your valley, it is a red flag that the underlying flashing or installation was faulty to begin with. A legitimate repair involves removing the damaged materials and replacing them, not sealing over the problem.
There are two main ways to shingle a valley: woven and open. * Woven Valleys: Shingles from both sides overlap through the valley. This can look clean, but if the shingles are not trimmed perfectly, they can bridge the gap and create a dam that catches water and debris. * Open Valleys: A metal strip (usually copper, galvanized steel, or aluminum) runs down the center. Shingles are cut back to reveal the metal.
A common mistake is mixing methods or failing to account for water speed. In Metro Detroit, where we deal with rapid snowmelt, open valleys are generally superior because they allow water to flow freely without resistance. The mistake happens when a contractor tries to "patch" an open valley by weaving in new shingles over the old metal, or vice versa, disrupting the water channel. For a deeper dive on the specific installation methods, check out our comprehensive guide on Roof Valley Repair.
In our climate, standard underlayment (felt paper) is often not enough in the valleys. Building codes in Michigan require "ice and water shield" in valleys and along eaves, but we frequently find older roofs or quick-fix repairs that skipped this step.
This self-adhering membrane sticks directly to the roof deck. If water gets past the shingles (due to wind-driven rain or ice dams), the membrane seals around the nails and prevents leakage. A major mistake is applying new shingles over an old, dried-out underlayment without adding this protection. If you are re-shingling a valley, the old underlayment must be removed, and fresh ice and water shield must be installed before the new flashing and shingles go down.
Nailing in the valley requires precision. The "valley line" is the imaginary center where water flows. Nails should never penetrate the center of the valley metal or the woven portion where water runs.
If a roofer nails too close to the center, they create a puncture point for water to enter. It seems like a minor error, but over time, the constant flow of water works its way down the nail shank and into the sheathing. We often see this on roof repair jobs where the crew was rushing. Correct installation involves "nailing far away"—keeping nails at least 6 to 8 inches away from the valley center and ensuring the shingle is secured by the adhesive strip rather than just mechanical fasteners near the critical water channel.
The angle of the shingle cut as it enters the valley is critical. If the shingles are cut too straight or at a 90-degree angle, they can dam up water. If they are cut too far back, they expose the underlayment or flashing to UV damage, which shortens its lifespan.
The best practice is to notch the corner of the shingle or cut it at an angle to guide water into the valley. A common mistake is leaving a "snag" or a sharp point that can catch leaves and twigs. Once debris accumulates, it holds moisture against the roof, leading to granule loss and mold. In a wooded area like parts of Oakland County, this debris buildup can rot a valley in just a few seasons.
On open valleys, the metal flashing is the hero. However, metal corrodes. Galvanized steel can rust; copper can develop pinholes if acidic runoff from asphalt shingles eats away at it over decades.
A common mistake is painting over rusted flashing to hide it rather than replacing it. Once metal flashing is compromised, it cannot be effectively sealed with coatings. The only fix is replacement. When Best Choice Roofing inspects a roof, we check the valley metal for pitting, rust stains, or separation at the seams. If the metal is failing, patching it is a waste of money; the valley needs to be rebuilt.
Valleys are highly susceptible to hail and wind damage. Hail can bruise the shingles in the valley, knocking off the granules that protect the asphalt. Wind can lift the shingle edges, breaking the seal.
Homeowners often make the mistake of assuming a small leak in the valley is just "maintenance" and filing a claim too late, or not filing at all because the damage looks minor from the ground. If you suspect storm damage, get a professional inspection immediately. We provide full insurance-claim help. We document the damage specific to the valleys and help you understand if the damage meets your policy's criteria for replacement. Attempting to pay out-of-pocket for a full valley rebuild when insurance could cover it is a financial mistake.
DIY valley repair is dangerous and rarely effective. The geometry of the roof changes how water flows, and what looks like a simple leak might actually be a complex issue involving step flashing, the chimney, or the dormer intersections.
Best Choice Roofing is a licensed, insured Metro Detroit roofing crew serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties. We know that every roof is unique. We offer same-day response on active leaks and storm damage. We never quote a firm price online because the roofer must confirm the exact scope of work and pricing after a free, on-site inspection.
Whether you need shingle repair, flashing work, or a full roof replacement, upfront pricing is our standard. We identify the specific roof valley repair common mistakes to avoid on your specific property and give you the honest truth about what needs to be fixed.
Get a Free Roof Inspection
Don't let a small valley leak turn into structural damage. Call Best Choice Roofing today for a free inspection and estimate.
Phone: (248) 206-5958
Website: Request a free inspection