Chimney Flashing Leaks: Common Mistakes to Avoid

In Metro Detroit, we see our fair share of heavy rain, snow, and ice. All that weather beats down on your roof, and the chimney is usually the first line of defense to fail. When we talk to homeowners in Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties, the story is often the same: water stains on the ceiling near the fireplace. Understanding chimney flashing leaks common mistakes to avoid is the only way to stop the cycle of patching and re-patching. When chimney flashing leaks are ignored or fixed incorrectly, they inevitably lead to extensive roof leaks & water damage that roofs the framing structure.

Flashing is the metal barrier that seals the gap between your chimney and the roof shingles. It is not a place to cut corners. Here is a breakdown of the specific errors we find on job sites and how you can ensure your home is protected.

1. Using Roofing Tar or Caulk as a Permanent Solution

The most common mistake we see is the "tar trap." A homeowner notices a small drip, buys a bucket of roofing cement, and smears it over the base of the chimney. It holds for a few months, maybe a season. But tar is not a flexible, long-term sealant.

In Michigan, the temperature swing between summer and winter is extreme. Your roof deck expands and contracts. Tar dries out, cracks, and pulls away from the brick and the metal. Once it cracks, water wicks right underneath it and sits against the wood sheathing. By the time you see the stain inside, the wood is often rotting.

The Fix: Proper flashing involves metal-to-metal contact. We remove the old tar and install step flashing and counter-flashing. If you see a glob of black tar on your chimney, it is a temporary bandage, not a cure.

2. Improper Step Flashing Installation

Step flashing consists of L-shaped pieces of metal woven into the shingle courses. Each piece must overlap the one below it. A frequent error is installers laying the step flashing on top of the shingles or nailing them through the face of the flashing.

When step flashing is nailed through the face, you create a hole right in the middle of your waterproof barrier. Water travels down the shingle, hits the nail head, and follows the shank into the house. Furthermore, if the flashing is not woven correctly with each row of shingles, water can bypass the metal entirely and run down the chimney chase.

The Fix: Step flashing must be woven into the shingles. The only part that should be exposed is the vertical leg against the chimney. The horizontal leg must be covered by the shingle course above it.

3. Ignoring the Need for a Cricket (Saddle)

If your chimney is wide (typically wider than 30 inches), it acts like a dam. Water and snow hit the wide backside of the chimney and pool. Without a diversion, this water backs up under the shingles and flashing.

Many homes, especially older ones in Metro Detroit, were built without a cricket—a small peaked roof structure installed behind the chimney to divert water around the sides. Without it, the open valley behind the chimney is a high-risk zone for leaks during our heavy spring rains.

The Fix: If you have a wide chimney and do not have a cricket, you need one. It is a code requirement in many jurisdictions now for a reason. It protects the roof transition and prevents the "dam" effect that forces water into your home.

4. Failed Counter-Flashing or Mortar Joints

The step flashing covers the roof side, but counter-flashing covers the vertical leg of the step flashing. This counter-flashing must be embedded into the mortar joints of the brick chimney.

Over time, mortar deteriorates. When the mortar cracks or falls out, the counter-flashing becomes loose. Gaps open up between the brick and the metal. Another mistake is using surface-mounted counter-flashing that is simply glued or caulked to the brick rather than cut into the masonry groove (reglet). Glued-on flashing pulls away easily due to thermal expansion.

The Fix: We cut a reglet into the brick mortar and insert the counter-flashing, then seal it with high-grade masonry sealant. This locks the flashing into the chimney structure so it cannot pull away.

5. Using the Wrong Materials

Galvanized steel is common, but in harsh climates, it rusts. If the original installer used cheap metal or failed to paint the cut edges of the flashing, rust will set in within a few years. Once rust eats through the metal, the barrier is gone.

Furthermore, using a soft metal like aluminum that doesn't match the durability of the surrounding roofing materials can lead to early failure. In areas with high wind, the flashing must be rigid enough to resist lifting.

The Fix: We recommend high-quality, corrosion-resistant metals like painted steel or copper, depending on the roof type. Ensuring the metal is painted or coated immediately after cutting prevents edge rust.

The Consequence of Delay

When you spot these issues, acting fast is critical. Small chimney leaks turn into big problems quickly. The water entering through the chimney chase runs down the framing, soaking the insulation, drywall, and ceiling joists. This leads to mold growth and compromised structural integrity. If you suspect you have roof leaks & water damage, waiting for the "next big storm" to test it is a gamble you will lose.

Why Professional Inspection Matters

Climbing onto a roof to inspect flashing is dangerous for the average homeowner. Diagnosing the specific failure point—whether it is the step flashing, the cricket, or the counter-flashing—requires experience. At Best Choice Roofing, we serve homeowners across Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and the surrounding Michigan counties. We know exactly what to look for regarding the freeze-thaw cycles specific to this region.

We offer same-day response on active leaks and storm damage. Whether it is a simple flashing repair or part of a larger insurance claim due to hail or wind damage, we handle the legwork. We provide free inspections and estimates, and we never quote a firm price online. An experienced roofer needs to see the specific pitch and condition of your roof to confirm exact pricing after a thorough, on-site inspection.

If you are dealing with water stains or suspect your chimney flashing is failing, do not rely on buckets or tar. Get a professional assessment.


Get a Free Roof Inspection

Best Choice Roofing is a licensed, insured Metro Detroit crew. We specialize in roof leak repair, storm and hail damage, shingle repair, full roof replacement, flashing, vents, and gutters. We provide upfront pricing and full insurance-claim help.

Call us today at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.