If you are preparing for a roof replacement or dealing with a persistent leak, you need to understand roof underlayment. It is the unsung hero of your roofing system. While shingles provide the first line of defense against sun and rain, the underlayment is the critical barrier that protects your roof deck from wind-driven rain and ice dams. In Metro Detroit, where freeze-thaw cycles and heavy storms are common, skipping on this layer or installing it incorrectly is a recipe for structural damage.
This guide breaks down what you need to know about the materials, the code requirements for Michigan, and how to ensure your contractor installs it right.
Roof underlayment is a waterproof or water-resistant barrier installed directly onto the roof deck. It sits underneath the shingles (or metal roofing) and on top of the sheathing (plywood or OSB).
Its primary job is to shed water that manages to get beneath the shingles. Shingles are designed to shed water quickly, but they are not waterproof seals. Wind-driven rain can force water up the edges of shingles. If that water hits the bare wood deck, it will rot. The underlayment bridges the gap, ensuring the water rolls off the roof and into your gutters rather than into your attic.
Not all underlayment is created equal. When you look at proposals from contractors, you will generally see three types of materials.
This is the traditional option, often called "felt paper" or "tar paper." It used to be the industry standard. * Composition: It is made from a base of organic or fiberglass mat saturated with asphalt. * Weight: You will see it rated as 15-lb or 30-lb. Thicker is generally better, but 30-lb felt can be heavy and difficult to install on hot days. * Pros: It is breathable, allowing moisture vapor from inside the house to escape, which helps prevent wood rot. It is also usually the cheapest option. * Cons: It can tear easily during installation. If left exposed to the sun for too long before shingles are applied, it dries out and becomes brittle.
Synthetic underlayment has largely replaced felt as the preferred choice for professional crews, including those at Best Choice Roofing. * Composition: Made from polypropylene or polyethylene, often with a fiberglass scrim for strength. * Pros: It is much stronger than felt. It lies flat and doesn't wrinkle as easily. It is highly resistant to UV damage, meaning it can sit exposed on the roof for weeks if a storm delays the job. It also has better slip-resistance for installers. * Cons: It generally costs more than felt, though the price gap has narrowed in recent years.
This is a specialized membrane used in "high-risk" areas. It is sticky on the back and seals directly to the wood deck. * Usage: Building codes in Michigan require this in valleys and along the eaves (the bottom edge of the roof). * Function: It is self-sealing. If a nail is driven through it, the rubber closes back up around the nail. This is vital for preventing leaks caused by ice dams.
In Metro Detroit, ice dams are a major concern. An ice dam forms when heat from your attic melts the bottom layer of snow on the roof. The water runs down the roof until it hits the cold overhang (eaves), where it refreezes. This ice builds up and creates a dam. Subsequent melting snow then backs up behind the dam, forcing water under the shingles.
If you only have standard felt or synthetic underlayment in this area, the water pooling behind the ice dam can work its way through the overlaps and nails. However, if you have a rubberized ice and water shield installed extending at least two feet past the interior wall line (often going up to 3 or 4 feet on the roof), the sticky membrane seals around the nail shanks and prevents that backed-up water from leaking into the house.
If you are getting a roof replacement, you shouldn't just watch the shingles go on. You need to ensure the underlayment is installed correctly. Here is a practical checklist you can use today.
Ask your contractor specifically what they are using. * Good: 30-lb felt. * Better: Basic synthetic underlayment. * Best: High-performance synthetic with a high slip rating. * Non-Negotiable: Rubberized ice and water shield in valleys and at eaves.
Do not let a contractor "overlay" a new roof over an old one without addressing the deck. If they are tearing off the old roof (which they should), insist on a full layer of underlayment over the entire deck, not just patches in the valleys. In a heavy storm, water can get anywhere.
Underlayment courses must overlap each other to shed water. * Horizontal rows: The upper row must overlap the lower row. This ensures water runs down the top layer and off the roof, rather than seeping underneath the seam. * Valleys: The underlayment in the valley is critical. There should be a layer running up the valley (the bottom layer) and then the sides running over the top of that valley layer. If installed in reverse, water will run into the seam.
Underlayment must integrate properly with flashing (the metal around chimneys, skylights, and dormers). * Step Flashing: The underlayment should run over the roof deck and under the step flashing. The counter-flashing (or the chimney masonry) then goes over the step flashing. This "shingling" method directs water down the roof. * If you see the flashing sitting on top of the underlayment, that is a potential leak point.
Underlayment usually fails due to poor installation or age. * Poor Installation: If the crew leaves gaps, uses staples instead of plastic caps (staples can tear through), or installs the laps backward, the roof will leak. * Age: Felt paper can deteriorate over 15 to 20 years, becoming brittle. Synthetic lasts longer but can be compromised if the roof deck moves significantly.
If you are seeing stains on your ceiling after a heavy wind-driven rain (not necessarily an ice dam situation), but your shingles look intact from the ground, the underlayment may have failed. In these cases, you often need professional roof leak repair to locate the breach.
Many premium shingle manufacturers require specific types of underlayment to validate their warranty. If you install a $500/square architectural shingle over cheap 15-lb felt, the manufacturer might deny a claim if the roof fails.
Furthermore, the installation method matters. When you choose a crew, verify they understand the specific nailing patterns and overlap requirements for the material they are using. This technical expertise is why it is vital to learn how to choose a roofing contractor before signing a contract.
At Best Choice Roofing, we treat underlayment as the foundation of the roof. We see the damage caused by skipped corners in Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. A roof is only as good as its weakest layer, and the underlayment is often that layer if it is ignored.
We utilize high-grade synthetic underlayment for the main field and heavy-duty ice and water shield in all vulnerable transition areas. We also ensure the deck is dry and sound before installation. Because we are a licensed, insured Metro Detroit roofing crew, we adhere strictly to local building codes regarding ice barrier coverage—a necessity for our Michigan winters.
Whether you need a full roof replacement, shingle repair, or flashing work, we provide the same level of detail. We offer same-day response on active leaks and storm damage, with free inspections and estimates. We also provide full insurance-claim help to navigate the paperwork after a major storm.
You cannot see the condition of your underlayment from the ground. If your roof is over 15 years old, or if you have purchased an older home in the Metro Detroit area, a professional inspection is the only way to know if this critical layer is still doing its job.
Do not wait for a visible leak to appear. By the time you see water inside, the underlayment has failed, and the structural damage to the decking may already be done.
Contact Best Choice Roofing today for a free, no-obligation inspection. We will inspect the roof deck, flashing, and underlayment condition (if visible at vents or valleys) and provide upfront pricing for any necessary work. Never quote a firm price online; the roofer confirms exact pricing after a free inspection.
Call us at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.