Cedar & Wood Shake Roofs

Illustrative composite based on typical scenarios. Names, companies, and figures are representative examples, not a specific verified customer.

If you own a home in Metro Detroit, particularly in the older neighborhoods of Birmingham, Royal Oak, or the Grosse Pointes, you know that curb appeal is everything. Cedar & wood shake roofs offer a distinct, rustic aesthetic that asphalt shingles often struggle to replicate. However, living in Michigan means dealing with heavy snow loads, ice dams, and humid summers that can wreak havoc on natural roofing materials.

This guide is a straightforward, contractor-level breakdown of what you need to know about maintaining, repairing, or replacing a cedar roof in Wayne, Oakland, and Macomb counties. We aren't here to sell you on the romance of wood; we’re here to talk about longevity, performance, and how Best Choice Roofing handles the specific challenges posed by our local climate.

What Are Cedar & Wood Shake Roofs?

Before diving into repairs, it is essential to understand exactly what is sitting on top of your home. While often used interchangeably, there is a technical difference between wood shingles and wood shakes.

Wood Shingles are machine-cut. They are tapered and smooth, providing a more uniform, tailored look. They lay flat and create a very clean, neat roof line.

Wood Shakes are hand-split or sawn on one side. They are thicker, more textured, and irregular. Because they are split rather than cut along the grain, shakes have a much more rugged, rustic appearance. They are also generally more durable because the wood fibers remain intact rather than being sheared off by a saw.

In Michigan, both options are popular, but the thick shake is often preferred for its ability to withstand the brutal freeze-thaw cycles we experience in the winter. However, both types require specific maintenance that asphalt roofs do not.

Warning Signs: When to Call a Pro

Ignoring a wood roof leads to leaks that can compromise the structure of your home. Because cedar is a natural product, it reacts to the environment. Here are the specific signs that suggest you need roof repair metro detroit residents should watch for:

1. Curling and Cupping

This is the most common issue. As wood ages and dries out, it shrinks. If you look at your roof from the ground and the edges of the shakes are turning upward or the center is dipping down (cupping), the roof has lost its ability to shed water effectively. Once the wood curls, water can wick underneath and seep into the underlayment.

2. Cracking and Splitting

Michigan’s temperature swings are brutal. A hot summer day followed by a cool night causes the wood to expand and contract. Over years, this stress causes the shakes to crack longitudinally (along the grain) or cross-grain. Cross-grain cracks are particularly dangerous as they allow water to penetrate directly into the roof deck.

3. Moss and Algae Growth

In the shaded, humid areas of Metro Detroit, moss thrives. It might look "charming" to some, but moss is a roof killer. It holds moisture against the wood, preventing it from drying out after a rain. This constant wetness accelerates rot. If you see green or black patches on your roof, it needs to be addressed immediately.

4. Missing Shakes

High winds, which are common during autumn storms, can tear loose shakes right off the deck. Even one missing shake exposes the underlayment (or felt paper) to UV rays and weather, leading to rapid deterioration of the layers beneath.

5. Rotten Valleys and Flashing

The valleys—where two roof planes meet—take the brunt of the water flow. If the wood in the valleys looks soft, dark, or decayed, you have a critical failure point. Similarly, check the flashing around chimneys and dormers. If the wood touching the metal is crumbling, the flashing has likely failed.

How Best Choice Roofing Handles Wood Roofs

At Best Choice Roofing, we don't treat a cedar roof like an asphalt job. The approach is different, the materials are different, and the pacing is different. We are a licensed, insured Metro Detroit roofing crew serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding counties. We understand that a wood roof is a significant investment, and we treat it with the care it requires.

When we arrive for a free inspection, we are looking for the "health" of the wood, not just obvious leaks. We check the fasteners (often stainless steel or hot-dipped galvanized for cedar), the integrity of the flashings, and the ventilation in your attic.

Our process is designed to be transparent. We provide upfront pricing and full insurance-claim help if the damage is storm-related. Whether it is a roof leak repair, storm and hail damage assessment, shingle repair, or a full roof replacement, we walk you through the findings before we lift a hammer.

Cost Factors: What Influences the Price?

We never quote a firm price online because every roof is unique. The roofer confirms exact pricing after a free inspection. However, to help you budget, you can read more about specific financial planning here.

Generally, the cost is driven by these factors:

The Step-by-Step Process

If a replacement is necessary, you need a crew that knows the specific installation requirements of wood. A sloppy install on cedar looks terrible and fails fast. We follow a rigorous procedure, which you can read about in depth here.

Here is the high-level overview of how we handle a full cedar replacement:

  1. Protection and Tear-Off: We protect your landscaping and siding. Then, we strip the existing roof down to the deck. We never just go over old wood unless the structure absolutely demands it, as we need to see the decking.
  2. Deck Repair: Michigan winters can cause roof sheathing to rot. We replace any wet or rotten wood with fresh OSB or plywood.
  3. Installation of Underlayment: We install an ice-and-water barrier in the valleys and along the eaves to prevent ice dam leaks. You can learn more about why this layer is critical in our guide to roof underlayment.
  4. Ventilation: A cedar roof must breathe. If the attic space isn't properly ventilated, the wood will cook from the underneath and rot from the top. We ensure your intake and exhaust vents are balanced. Check our primer on roof ventilation basics to see why this matters.
  5. Application: We install the shakes starting at the eaves, working up. We use corrosion-resistant nails (usually stainless steel) because the acids in cedar will eat standard galvanized nails over time. We ensure proper spacing and exposure so the roof can shed water efficiently.

Repair vs. Replacement: Making the Call

One of the hardest decisions for a homeowner is whether to patch the roof or bite the bullet and replace it. At Best Choice Roofing, we are honest about this. We make money on repairs and replacements, so we have no incentive to upsell you if a repair will last.

When to Repair: * The damage is localized (e.g., a tree branch damaged one corner). * The shakes are generally in good shape, with maybe 10-15% failure. * The underlayment is still intact and dry.

When to Replace: * The roof is approaching 20-25 years old. * There are widespread signs of curling or cupping. * You can see multiple layers of roofing (indicating past "cover-ups"). * The cost of cumulative repairs approaches the cost of a new roof.

If you are unsure, call us. We offer same-day response on active leaks. We would rather come out, tell you it just needs a few shakes swapped, and save you thousands, than sell you a roof you don't need yet.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Cedar roofs are unforgiving if installed incorrectly. Over the years, we have been called in to fix plenty of disasters caused by other crews. To protect yourself, read our full list of common mistakes to avoid.

Here are the top three we see in Michigan:

  1. Poor Ventilation: Installing a tight wood roof without adequate attic airflow. This traps heat and moisture, turning the shakes into petri dishes for mold and rot.
  2. Using the Wrong Nails: Using electro-galvanized nails or staples. These rust and break, causing the shakes to slide off during the next heavy windstorm. We only use high-quality stainless steel or hot-dipped nails.
  3. Power Washing: Some contractors offer to "clean" your roof with a high-pressure washer. This is terrible for cedar. It blasts away the soft fibers of the wood, drastically reducing its remaining lifespan. If your roof needs cleaning, it should be done chemically and with low pressure.

Living with Cedar in Michigan

Owning a cedar & wood shake roof in Metro Detroit is a commitment. It is not a "install it and forget it" system like architectural asphalt. To get the full lifespan out of it, you need to keep the valleys clear of debris, ensure your overhanging trees are trimmed back (to prevent shade and moss buildup), and have it inspected annually.

However, when maintained correctly, there is nothing that matches the look and the insulation value of a real wood roof. It keeps your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter better than most other materials.

If you are seeing signs of wear, or if you just want a professional assessment of your roof's health, don't wait for a leak to appear in your living room.


Get a Free Inspection from Best Choice Roofing

We are a local crew, fully licensed and insured, serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties. We handle everything from roof leak repair and storm damage to full roof replacements, flashing, vents, and gutters.

We offer same-day response on active leaks and storm damage. We provide free inspections and estimates, upfront pricing, and full insurance-claim help.

Do not guess at the cost or the condition of your roof. The roofer confirms exact pricing after a free inspection.

Call us today at (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.