Illustrative composite based on typical scenarios. Names, companies, and figures are representative examples, not a specific verified customer.
Selling a home in Metro Detroit comes with its fair share of hurdles, but a roofing issue should not be the reason a deal falls through. This failed flashing roof repair case study follows a homeowner in Oakland County who faced a last-minute inspection nightmare just days before closing. The buyer’s inspector identified significant deterioration around the chimney and skylights. Instead of canceling the contract or accepting a lowball repair concession, the homeowner contacted Best Choice Roofing. We quickly assessed the situation, provided a transparent solution, and got the sale back on track. Here is the breakdown of how we addressed the repair to ensure the property passed the home sale inspection.
The scenario is common in older suburbs like Rochester Hills and Troy. The homeowner had listed the property and received an acceptable offer. During the due diligence period, the buyer hired a general home inspector. While the roof shingles appeared to be in fair condition from the ground, the inspector got up close and found the root cause of potential water damage: failed flashing.
Specifically, the inspection report noted three areas of concern: 1. Chimney Flashing: The mortar was crumbling, and the metal flashing where the brick met the shingles was pulling away. 2. Skylight Curbs: The rubber gaskets around the skylights had dried out and cracked. 3. Step Flashing: At the sidewall of the second-story dormer, the shingles were curling, exposing the flashing beneath.
The buyer’s agent demanded these items be repaired before closing or requested a $5,000 credit. The homeowner, already stressed by the moving process, needed a licensed professional who could provide a permanent fix, not a temporary caulk job. They reached out to Best Choice Roofing for a same-day assessment due to the active nature of the leak risk.
When our crew arrived at the property, we confirmed the home inspector’s findings but provided the necessary technical context. In many Michigan homes, flashing failures are the primary cause of roof leaks, often more so than missing shingles.
We climbed onto the roof to inspect the chimney and dormers. We found that the previous installer had relied heavily on roof cement (tar) to seal the flashing rather than proper mechanical fastening and metal integration. Over time, the tar becomes brittle and cracks, allowing water to seep behind the flashing and into the sheathing. This is a classic example of failed flashing.
Because the homeowner needed to provide proof of repair to the buyer's bank, we documented everything with photos. We checked the interior attic space for moisture staining on the decking. Fortunately, the damage was superficial to the roof structure and had not yet rotted the trusses, but it was only a matter of time before a heavy thunderstorm caused interior damage.
For homeowners dealing with active leaks or storm damage, understanding the scope of work is crucial. While this specific case was a pre-sale maintenance item, similar symptoms often result from storm damage. If you suspect your damage is weather-related, reviewing the roof insurance claim process is a vital step before paying out of pocket.
We presented the homeowner with an upfront estimate following our free inspection. The price was confirmed on-site—it was significantly less than the buyer’s requested credit, saving the homeowner money at the closing table.
Our repair plan focused on the "cut and stitch" method rather than a full replacement, as the shingles still had usable life left.
We removed the rows of shingles surrounding the chimney on all sides. We pulled out the old, rusted step flashing and counter-flashing. We then installed new galvanized steel step flashing, weaving it into the shingle courses to ensure water flows over the metal, not under it. We applied a new base of ice and water protection membrane directly against the brick before reinstalling the counter-flashing. Finally, we re-pointed the brick mortar where it met the roof line to seal the gap.
At the dormer, we repeated the process. We bent new aluminum step flashing to fit the tight corners where the roof met the vertical wall. We ensured each piece of flashing overlapped the one below it by at least two inches. This shingling method directs water down the roof surface.
For the skylights, we did not remove the units (which can be risky and expensive). Instead, we lifted the surrounding shingles and applied a high-grade polyurethane sealant under the flashing flanges. We then secured the flanges with new roofing nails and covered the nail heads with bituminous plastic cement.
The crew completed the work in a single day. We cleaned the site of all nails and debris, using magnetic sweepers to ensure the new buyers wouldn't find any sharp objects in the grass. If you are experiencing similar issues, you can read more about how we handle specific leaks in our guide to roof leak repair.
The day after the repair, the buyer’s home inspector returned to verify the work. Because we had replaced the metal flashing and restored the integrity of the water-shedding layers—rather than just smearing tar over the cracks—the inspector signed off on the roof immediately.
The report was updated to state that the roof repairs were professionally completed and that no further action was required. The closing proceeded on schedule. The homeowner was able to pass the home sale inspection without negotiating the price down, effectively paying for the repairs and preserving their equity at closing.
This composite case study highlights why "patching" a roof rarely satisfies a home inspector. Failed flashing is a structural defect in the water management system of the roof. In Metro Detroit, where freeze-thaw cycles can shift the roof deck, the metal must be able to move slightly without breaking the seal.
Best Choice Roofing serves Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties with this exact level of detail. We are a licensed and insured crew dedicated to keeping homes dry. Whether you are selling a home and need fast repairs, or you have noticed streaks on your walls during a rainstorm, we offer free inspections and estimates.
We never quote a firm price online because every roof penetration—chimneys, vents, and valleys—is unique. The roofer confirms exact pricing after a physical inspection to ensure accuracy.
Don't let a small leak turn into a failed sale.
Get Your Free Inspection Call Best Choice Roofing today at (248) 206-5958 or request your free estimate online at roofs.bestchoice411.com.