How a Failed Flashing Homeowner Got the Insurance Claim Approved with Best Choice Roofing

Illustrative composite based on typical scenarios. Names, companies, and figures are representative examples, not a specific verified customer.

When it comes to Michigan weather, the integrity of your roof system is tested constantly. This failed flashing roof repair case study examines a common scenario in Metro Detroit: a homeowner facing significant water damage due to compromised flashing, and the subsequent process of securing insurance coverage. We will look at how a homeowner in Oakland County worked with Best Choice Roofing to identify the root cause, document the damage effectively, and navigate the complexities of a claim to ensure the roof was restored correctly.

The Problem: Misdiagnosed Leaks and Structural Risk

The homeowner, "Mark," noticed a discoloration on his ceiling drywall directly adjacent to his chimney stack. Initially, he assumed the issue was related to the shingles. Like many homeowners, he climbed a ladder with a tube of caulk and attempted to seal the visible gap between the brick and the shingles. Two weeks later, a heavy rainstorm hit the region, and the leak returned, this time causing water to drip onto his hardwood flooring.

The problem was not the shingles themselves, but the failed flashing. Flashing is the metal material installed to redirect water away from critical areas like chimneys, skylights, and valleys. In Mark’s case, the step flashing had corroded and pulled away from the brick chimney due to thermal expansion and contraction over the years. Water was running behind the flashing, soaking the roof deck, and entering the interior wall. By the time Mark called a professional, the structural integrity of the roof sheathing near the chimney was compromised, and mold was beginning to form in the attic space.

The Inspection: Identifying the Storm Damage

Mark contacted Best Choice Roofing for a free inspection. As a licensed and insured crew serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding counties, they prioritize same-day responses for active leaks. The inspector arrived and immediately identified the issue as a failure in the chimney counter-flashing and step flashing. However, the inspector looked deeper to determine the cause.

During the inspection, they found that while the flashing was old and corroded, recent high winds had exacerbated the problem. The wind had lifted the shingles adjacent to the chimney, breaking the seal that remained. This is a critical distinction in roofing: long-term wear and tear is maintenance, but sudden wind damage that accelerates a failure is often an insurable event.

The team documented the corroded metal, the lifted shingles, and the water damage to the decking and interior. They explained to Mark that a simple patch would not pass code or prevent future leaks. The chimney required a complete re-flashing, which involves removing the shingles around the chimney, installing new rust-resistant metal, and ensuring proper overlap into the brick mortar joints. This level of roof leak repair requires technical precision to ensure the water barrier is continuous.

The Fix: Navigating the Insurance Process

Mark was concerned about the cost. A full re-flashing and deck repair is a significant investment. He asked the inspector if this was something insurance would cover. The inspector explained that coverage depends on the cause of loss. Since the recent wind storm had physically damaged the components and led to the interior leak, it was worth filing a claim.

Many homeowners struggle to communicate the technical realities of roofing to insurance adjusters. Best Choice Roofing offers full insurance-claim help to bridge this gap. They assisted Mark in filing the claim and were present during the adjuster's visit.

When the adjuster arrived, the Best Choice Roofing representative walked them through the damage: 1. The Wind Lift: Showing the broken seal on the shingles caused by the recent storm. 2. The Corroded Flashing: Demonstrating how the wind intrusion turned a maintenance item into an active leak. 3. The Interior Damage: Providing photos of the stained drywall and wet decking to prove the leak was sudden and accidental, not gradual neglect.

By guiding the adjuster through the roof insurance claim process, the team ensured the scope of loss was accurate. The initial estimate from the insurance company was low, assuming a simple patch. However, the roofer provided a detailed supplement citing local building codes requiring full removal and replacement of the flashing in that area, rather than covering it with a membrane.

The Result: A Restored Roof and Approved Claim

Because the damage was documented thoroughly and correlated with the weather event, Mark got the insurance claim approved for the full scope of work. The final settlement covered the removal of shingles around the chimney, the replacement of approximately 30 square feet of rotted roof decking, the installation of new galvanized steel step flashing and counter-flashing, and the re-installation of matching shingles. It also covered the interior drywall repair.

Best Choice Roofing completed the project in two days. They installed the new flashing correctly, tucking it into the mortar cuts of the brick and weaving it properly with the shingles to create a watershed effect. They also inspected and cleared the gutters near the chimney to ensure water would flow away from the foundation.

For Mark, the result was a roof that was properly waterproofed and a financial outcome that didn't require him to pay out of pocket beyond his deductible. He avoided the "band-aid" fix that would have led to recurring leaks and further damage.

Lessons for Homeowners

This case highlights the importance of professional inspections. What looks like a small leak can be a symptom of a major failure in the roof’s water-shedding system. Furthermore, distinguishing between "old age" and "storm damage" is the key to getting a claim approved. A licensed contractor knows how to present the evidence so the insurance carrier understands the necessity of the repair.

If you suspect you have failed flashing or have noticed leaks after a storm, do not wait. Delaying repairs allows water to rot the structure of your home.


Get Your Free Roof Inspection

Best Choice Roofing is a licensed, insured Metro Detroit roofing crew serving Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and surrounding Michigan counties. We provide same-day response on active leaks and storm damage, free inspections and estimates, upfront pricing, and full insurance-claim help. Our services include roof leak repair, storm and hail damage, shingle repair, full roof replacement, flashing, vents, and gutters.

Note: We never quote a firm price online. The roofer confirms exact pricing after a free inspection based on the specific needs of your roof.

Call (248) 206-5958 or request a free inspection at roofs.bestchoice411.com.